Roof Tiles vs Shingles: What's the Best Roofing Material for Your Home?
- Susan Holloway
- Jun 13
- 4 min read
Updated: Jun 25
In my years of owning homes across Colorado, Arizona, and Wyoming, I've learned that a good roof over your head is more than just a saying—it's the truth. Your roof is your home's first line of defense against the elements, and choosing the right one can save you money, and headaches, and even add a beautiful finishing touch to your property.
Here at Homeowners United, we know that dealing with homeownership challenges should be easier. So today, I want to break down the different types of roofing materials out there. It’s not as complicated as it sounds, and knowing the basics can help you make a smart decision for your home and your wallet. As always, if you need a professional inspection for your roof, use our Find a Pro Tool.
The Classic Choice: Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material in the U.S., and for good reason. They are affordable and come in a wide variety of colors and styles, making them a versatile option for many homes.
Lifespan: You can generally expect an asphalt shingle roof to last between 20 to 30 years. There are different types, like 3-tab and architectural shingles, with the latter typically lasting longer.
Cost & Value: Asphalt shingles are one of the most budget-friendly options upfront. According to a 2024 report, a roofing replacement with asphalt shingles can recoup about 56.9% of its cost in resale value.
Climate Considerations: They hold up well in a variety of weather conditions. In a place like Colorado, they are a cost-effective way to handle snow and hail. However, in the intense Arizona heat, they can deteriorate faster than some other materials. For the notorious winds in Wyoming, you'd want to look at high-wind-rated architectural grades.
Good to Know: Many manufacturers now offer "cool-roof" asphalt shingles with reflective granules that absorb less heat, which can help with energy bills.
The Durable Performer: Metal Roofing
I’ve seen more and more metal roofs popping up, and it’s easy to see why. They are incredibly durable and offer a modern, sleek look.
Lifespan: A metal roof can last a whopping 40 to 70 years.
Cost & Value: The initial cost is higher than asphalt, but their longevity can make them a great investment. A metal roof replacement might see a 48.1% return on investment at resale.
Energy Efficiency: This is where metal really shines. Metal roofs reflect solar heat, which can lead to significant savings on your cooling costs, a big plus in hot climates like Arizona. Some studies suggest potential energy savings of up to 40%.
Climate Considerations: Metal is a fantastic choice for snowy and windy areas. The smooth surface helps snow slide right off, which is a great feature for those heavy Colorado and Wyoming snows. They are also fire-resistant, an important consideration in many parts of the West.
The Timeless Look: Tile Roofing
For a classic, elegant look, it’s hard to beat tile. Whether clay or concrete, these roofs are known for their beauty and resilience.
Lifespan: With proper maintenance, a tile roof can last over 50 years, and some even up to 100 years.
Cost & Value: Tile is a more expensive option, but its long life and curb appeal can be worth it.
Energy Efficiency: The air gap under the tiles creates a thermal barrier, helping to keep your home cooler in the summer. Lighter-colored tiles are especially effective at reflecting sunlight.
Climate Considerations: Tile is an excellent choice for the Arizona heat and is highly resistant to fire. It can also withstand high winds. However, the weight of a tile roof is a significant factor, and your home's structure needs to be able to support it, especially in areas with heavy snow loads. Tile roofs in Arizona, for example, are known for their amazing long term durability and energy efficiency.
The Natural Beauty: Wood Shakes and Shingles
For a rustic and natural aesthetic, wood shakes and shingles are a beautiful option.
Lifespan: A well-maintained wood roof can last between 30 and 50 years.
Cost & Value: The cost is generally higher than asphalt shingles.
Energy Efficiency: Wood is a natural insulator, so it can help with your home's overall energy efficiency by keeping it cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter.
Climate Considerations: Wood shakes can be rated to withstand high winds. However, they are more vulnerable to fire, though pressure-treated, fire-retardant versions are available and often required. In dry climates, maintenance is key to prevent cracking and warping.
Making Your Choice
Ultimately, the best roof for you depends on your budget, your local climate, and the style of your home. As an example, the debate between roof tiles vs. shingles is largely dependent on you climate and the weather that your climate consistently brings. The good news is that the roofing market is growing, with more and more options becoming available. In 2023, asphalt shingles held the largest market share due to their affordability and durability.
No matter what you choose, remember that proper installation is just as important as the material itself. A poorly installed roof won’t perform well, no matter how much you paid for the materials. This is the reason we have our Find a Pro tool available to our readers. If you need a trusted professional to do a free inspection on the condition of your roof, click here.
We at Homeowners United are here to help you navigate these kinds of decisions with confidence. A new roof is a big investment, but with the right knowledge, you can protect your home and even add to its value for years to come.
